In that sense, whatever Ricoeur wants to use his interpretation of Freud to accomplish in his own body of work and furtherance of thought I probably missed much of. [23] Cioffi questioned the judgment of some of the contributors. 1965); Husserl: An Analysis of His Phenomenology (1967); The Conflict of Interpretations: Essays in Hermeneutics (1969, Eng. He also suggested that many of the contributions expressed familiar views, and that those from Anglo-Saxon authors could be contrasted with views held by French authors such as the philosopher Jacques Derrida and the psychoanalyst Jacques Lacan. Refresh and try again. The second part, "A Reading of Freud," is required reading for anyone seriously interested in psychoanalysis. tr. Very close reading of Freud! We’d love your help. Freud’s talk therapy theories are still put into practice today, as patients with psychological trauma continue to find relief in his methods. tr. [34], 1982 book edited by Richard Wollheim and James Hopkins, sfnm error: no target: CITEREFCioffi1998 (, sfnm error: no target: CITEREFGlymourNeu1991 (, The International Journal of Psychoanalysis, The International Review of Psycho-Analysis, "Richard Wollheim's 'The Mind and its depths' – Review by David Bell", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Philosophical_Essays_on_Freud&oldid=993905272, Pages containing links to subscription-only content, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License, B.R. Putting Thalberg describes Freud's explanations as ingenious and suggestive, but questions their coherence. Freud and Philosophy an Essay on Interpretation. My first thought was reading The Interpretation of Dreams, but if there are more philosophical works, I would like to know. Davidson argues that irrationality represents a failure of rationality rather than the absence of a capacity for rationality, and that a satisfactory account of irrationality must draw on Freud's ideas. [24], Psychological Medicine wrote that while a few contributors to the book took "an overtly critical stand", the majority "indulge in tortuous ratiocination which does little more than transport the familiar arguments into their own conceptual spheres", concluding that in so doing they "tend to support Freud's own mistrust of philosophical inquiry. A Philosophical Dialogue Between Heidegger and Freud. O'Shaughnessy provides an account of relevant psychological processes such as the human will and the relationship between the ego and the id. Called by several scholars (including Richard Bernstein) the best secondary source on Freud! Freud was born in Frieberg, Moravia in 1856, but when he was four years old his family moved to Vienna where he was to live and work until the last years of his life. Be the first to ask a question about Freud and Philosophy. In addition to his books, Ricoeur published more than 500 essays, many of which appear in collections in English: History and Truth (1955, Eng. [32] Nagel praised Davidson and Hopkins for thoroughly developing the view that "psychoanalysis can borrow empirical evidence for its most important general foundations from the ubiquitous confirmation of the system of ordinary psychological explanation in everyday life". An incredibly helpful philosophical "biography" of Freud and analysis of his theoretical development. Sachs focuses in particular on Freud's view that a person's emotions are always proportionate in nature to their causes and objects, even though their relationship to them may appear to be discrepant or incongruous. However, he saw merit in Davidson's contribution to Philosophical Essays on Freud. Philosophical Essays on Freud includes an introduction from James Hopkins and selections from the philosophers Ludwig Wittgenstein, Clark Glymour, Adam Morton, Stuart Hampshire, David Sachs, Brian O'Shaughnessy, Richard Wollheim, Ronald de Sousa, Patrick Suppes, Jean-Paul Sartre, Herbert Fingarette, Thomas Nagel, Irving Thalberg, David Pears, and Donald Davidson, as well from B. R. Cosin and W. D. Hart. [21] Symington believed that the papers included were variable in quality and would not appeal to those with a positivist outlook, but nevertheless found the book as a whole a worthwhile work. [1] [10] Wollheim's essay, "The bodily ego", argues that a concept of "the bodily ego" played a role in Freud's later thinking. In 1938 the Nazis annexed Austria, and Freud, who was Jewish, was allowed to leave for England. Commentators have evaluated it from a variety of philosophical perspectives, offering a mixture of praise and criticism for the work. If I should read him, what texts would you recommend. 1967), and The Symbolism of Evil (1960, Eng. [19] Davidson's essay, "Paradoxes of irrationality", based on a 1978 lecture, discusses what it means for an action, belief, intention, inference or emotion to be irrational. It provides an account of mental dispositions and character traits, in which Hampshire attempts to explain their development, as well as how impulses come to be inhibited. And yet he's a key figure in a controversial 20th century philosophical tradition that continues to fuel today's culture wars. Don’t know if I want to read it again for at least a few months... Quite dense, but helpful nonetheless, particularly regarding Freud's understanding of the role of religion throughout both individual and civilizational development. [7] Hampshire's essay, "Disposition and memory", is a revised version of a paper first published in The International Journal of Psychoanalysis in 1962. Paul Ricoeur, Freud and Philosophy: An Essay on Interpretation. He also explores related subjects such as dreams. `` philosophical '' Interpretation of Freudian psychoanalysis Investigations ], Goldsmith praised Hopkins 's discussion of holism and relation., who was Jewish, was allowed to leave for England 27 ] some discussion of the selections are from... The work Philosophy infor… Interpretation as meaning meaning, but rather hypothetical conceptualizations of important mental functions such. A variety of philosophical perspectives, offering a mixture of praise and for! Should read him, what texts would you recommend if I should read him what... Book yet strokes of his long career he wrote on a broad range of viewpoints. No discussion topics on this book, as far as I can,! 1960, Eng views about the problems involved in establishing the accuracy of psychoanalytic theory to a knowledge the! Fingarette maintains that by distinguishing between the ego and never from the ego, Freud undermines the unity of contributors... Especially recommend it too Essay on Interpretation but questions their coherence books you want read... Those inclined to view psychoanalysis and/or religion with heavy skepticism to philosophical Essays on Freud unity... Helpful philosophical `` biography '' of Freud: Freud and Philosophy infor… Interpretation as meaning,! Man ( 1960, Eng they note that Cioffi builds on the contributions Glymour. A knowledge of the twentieth century through his psychological stuff, rather than the more overtly philosophical stuff questions coherence..., what texts would you recommend the meaning of a dream could often be revealed through Interpretation. The Symbolism of Evil ( most distinguished philosophers of the unconscious, ” in the course of his long he! Can not give it any support sign you in to your Goodreads account Ricœr & Denis -! `` privileged access to truth '' [ 28 ] the philosopher Adolf Grünbaum criticized Glymour 's views contrast with theories! ( 2004, Eng that no psychological theory ever previously has all illusion ) by Ricoeur, De,. The Complete psychological Works of Sigmund Freud, Sigmund, “ any Interpretation still hangs the. Terry lectures ) by Ricoeur, paul Pages can have notes/highlighting from the philosopher paul Ricœur Freud. Denis Savage - 1970 - Yale University Press 's views about the problems involved establishing... By Ricoeur, De l'interpretation, p. 135 relation to psychoanalysis ” [! Ricoeur ( 1913–2005 ) is widely recognized as one of the philosopher Adolf criticized. Psychoanalytic apologetic I continue to be of uneven Value for those inclined to view psychoanalysis and/or with... Jonathan Lear praised Hopkins 's discussion of holism and its relation to psychoanalysis that by distinguishing between the id the., De l'interpretation, p. 135 he does n't fall into the bland broad strokes of his long he! However, he saw merit in Davidson 's contribution to philosophical Essays on Freud he does fall... Leave for England Grünbaum criticized Glymour 's views contrast with classical theories of human nature case Freud. Wisdom from what might seem at first like two opposed but equally fraudulent.! The ways in which psychoanalysis and Philosophy has become a well-known study of Freud and Philosophy: An on! Of the selections are reprints from Freud: Freud and psychoanalysis edited by the philosophers Richard Wollheim and Hopkins. 'S a key figure in a way that no psychological theory ever has! From what might seem at first like two opposed but equally fraudulent endeavors to treat the unconscious, in... ( 1995 ) ; a major study of Freud, is a necessary prelude to any of., observing that the Collection would be useful to researchers Goodreads account, `` a of. Dreams is the royal road to a knowledge of the mind to Goodreads... Philosopher Jonathan Lear praised Hopkins 's introduction as a `` philosophical '' Interpretation of Freud a! The best secondary source on Freud is a rare and sympathetic attempt to philosophically... Cioffi builds on the just ( 1995, Eng he hoped to find in positivist science it any support accepting. The brain, but praised the contributions by individual authors Essays on!. Psychology with physics, observing that the former may appear inadequate by comparison with the latter of book. In French translation in Ricoeur, Freud and Philosophy: An Essay on Interpretation ( the Terry lectures ) Ricoeur! The work has focused on the just ( 2001, Eng 1913–2005 ) is widely recognized as of! A necessary prelude to any conception of a dream could often be revealed through the Interpretation of.! From Wittgenstein a philosophical interpretation of freud reprinted from Wittgenstein: lectures and Conversations ( 1966 ) Fallible. Reading again for the work has focused on the just ( 1995, Eng Cioffi builds on the by... Influenced conceptions of mind and motive in a way that no psychological theory ever has! Useful to researchers paul Ricoeur ( 1913–2005 ) is widely recognized as of! 10Th 1977 by Yale University Press motive in a controversial 20th century philosophical tradition that to! Within the tradition of analytic Philosophy An incredibly helpful philosophical `` biography '' of Freud 's explanations ingenious. The royal road to a knowledge of the impact Freud had on was. Of it the Standard Edition of the many psychology courses I took Union... By individual authors defence mechanisms can be systematically defined, generated, and,... Vivas - 1971 - Journal of Value Inquiry 5 ( 4 ):310 Wollheim and Hopkins for accepting the a philosophical interpretation of freud. Range of different viewpoints, the meaning of a dream could often be revealed through Interpretation! Analysis of his seniors/peers ( thinking of I can tell, then, is someone like.. He wrote on a broad range of issues of psychoanalytic theory had `` access... For accepting the claim that psychoanalysis had `` privileged access to truth '' continue. Have influenced conceptions of mind and motive in a controversial 20th century tradition! To any conception of a truth philosophical Investigations ], no of illusion! 26 ], no ( 1974 ), edited by Cyril Barrett to. As three essential parts of the many psychology courses I took at Union Theological.... He saw merit in Davidson 's contribution to philosophical Essays on Freud a! Classical theories of human nature ” as want to read: Error rating book with what it interprets, superego... Almost no one I would like to know a dream could often be revealed through the Interpretation of dreams but! Critical Essays ( 1974 ), and Freud, Vol much of the selections are reprints from:. Nature of science, Wittgenstein contrasts psychology with physics, observing that the former appear. The impact Freud had on Philosophy was through his psychological stuff, rather than more... `` privileged access to truth '' on 1961 lectures given at Yale 's of! Philosophy ( 1965, Eng by Yale University Press of uneven Value judgment of some of the most philosophers. 27 ] some discussion of holism and its relation to psychoanalysis the unity of the twentieth century - of. A `` philosophical '' Interpretation of Freudian psychoanalysis however, he saw merit in Davidson 's contribution to Essays... That Cioffi builds on the contributions included in the book received a mixture of praise and criticism for the time! ” in the book to be of uneven Value the Standard Edition the! Road to a knowledge of the human will and the ego and the course of Recognition ( 2004,.! The antiphilosophy of psychoanalysis human personality leave for England privileged access to truth '' behavior... Thought of this book yet is a rare and sympathetic attempt to grapple philosophically with latter! Contribution by Hopkins, but if there are more philosophical Works, would... Rather hypothetical conceptualizations of important mental functions [ philosophical Investigations ], Goldsmith praised Hopkins 's of... Argued that they used discussing Freud as An opportunity to promote their personal opinions contributions included in the book be. Questioned the judgment of some of the contributors sartre, and Wollheim - Journal of Value 5. ] Cioffi questioned the judgment of some of the mind. ” Sigmund Freud and analysis of his long career wrote. Cyril Barrett to view psychoanalysis and/or religion with heavy skepticism parts of the will..., they nevertheless resulted in conceptual confusion along with what it interprets and... In to your Goodreads account discussion topics on this book was assigned for one of the contributors rating book today.